Contrasting Silkos Yellow Woman and Chopins Story of an Hour :: comparison compare contrast essays

Contrasting Silkos Yellow cleaning lady and Chopins Story of an HourOn the surface, the booster units of Silkos Yellow Woman and Chopins Story of an Hour seem to score weensy in common. Yet upon closer inspection, both stories relate tales of women who are reduce by the social tenets that define their roles as wives.From the viewpoint of Western society, the teller of Yellow Woman might be considered immoral for her willing knowledgeable look with a stranger. However, the stories related by her grandfather of the Yellow Woman demonstrate within her culture a more accepting strength of her brief interlude Yellow Woman went away with the spirit from the northbound and lived with him and his relatives. She was gone a long time, but then one solar day she came back and brought twin boys.(188) Her grandfather certainly liked telling the stories and seems to have admired the Yellow Woman on some level. Other societies do not share the Western idea of moral invokeual behavior. T he Egyptian ruling class, for example, sometimes married brother to sister, and other cultures have incarnate fertility rites into their belief systems. Even within our own society, conjugal unions to cousins, which are considered damage today, were not uncommon in past centuries. Given that her attitude regarding sex and marriage might differ from the Western norm, the central conflict of the storey seems to be the narrators desire for freedom to choose her own destiny versus her more Westernized view of her role as wife and mother, a role that is traditionally subservient to the husband in Western society. There is the sense that she finds her quotidian life dull, though perhaps not unhappy, and when a chance encounter turned sexual, she again takes on a subservient role to a male. Her inability to make sense of her conflicting feelings causes her to appear weak and abstr identification numbered in character and portrays her in a negative light.By contrast, Louise Mallard, th e protagonist in Chopins Story of an Hour, is a moral woman and engaging wife, at least by Western standards. Her life is defined by the accepted social ideal of a husbands will as final. She is so inured to this concept that only upon hearing the news of his death does her rightful(a) feeling of something too subtle and elusive to name (199) come forth. What she acknowledges to herself is that her marriage is not happy for her and she often resents her subservient role and a charitable intention or a cruel intention made the act seem no less a crime.